Skip to main content

ESC is an alliance of European organisations that strives to reduce the impact of
modern communications and electricity use on health and the environment.
We are not against technology, but we are pro safe technology and safe connections.

Legal Cases

#EHS #USA #Winning #2007
Alaska Supreme Court upholds awarding an AT&T equipment installer 100% disability as a result of his workplace electromagnetic field exposure to radiofrequency (RF) radiation at levels slightly above the FCC RF limit.

#EHS #Australia #Winning #2013
Dr. McDonald vs. Comcare, specialist received 75% of salary, unable to work because his employer did not provide protection from radiation even though he was diagnosed with EHS.
https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/cth/aat/2013/105.html

#EHS #USA #Winning #2014
A Manhattan nurse practitioner with a rare brain disorder won a $4 million judgment last week against New York Presbyterian Hospital — seven years after she sued the hospital for forcing her to work in units that exacerbated her painful condition.
https://nypost.com/2014/11/23/nurse-with-rare-brain-disorder-wins-4m-suit-against-hospital

#EHS #France #Winning #2015:
French court awards woman disability grant for ‘allergy to gadgets’. Court recognises that Marine Richard, 39, suffers from electromagnetic hypersensitivity to everyday devices such as mobile phones. Ms. Richard lives in the mountains of south-west France, in a renovated barn with no electricity, and drinks water from the well. A Toulouse court has ruled that she is entitled to a disability allowance of around 800 euros ($912) a month for three years.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/aug/27/french-court-awards-woman-disability-grant-for-allergy-to-gadgets

#EHS #Spain #Winning #2016
A telecommunications engineer who worked for the technology company Ericsson has been declared unfit for work due to electrohypersensitivity, a neurological syndrome that appears when exposed to computers, cell phones, wifi signals or spaces with high electrical and electromagnetic activity. The High Court of Justice (TSJM) of Madrid has recognized his problem, which prevents him from continuing to work without becoming ill, and has ruled that he is entitled to a disability benefit.
https://www.heraldo.es/noticias/sociedad/2016/08/02/un-ingeniero-telecomunicaciones-con-electrosensibilidad-logra-incapacidad-laboral-993859-310.html

#EHS #fibromyalgia #Spain #Winning #2017
The family of Rubén F. B., a 47 year old plumber, breathes a sigh of relief after learning of the unprecedented ruling of the Social Court, number 4, of Castellón by which, for the first time in Spain, a patient suffering from fibromyalgia, multiple chemical sensitivity and electrosensitivity is recognized as permanently disabled to the degree of severe disability. These ailments have forced this man to live isolated in a house.
https://www.elperiodicomediterraneo.com/castello/2017/03/01/cuatro-anos-calvario-enfermo-aislado-41575289.html

#EHS #France #Winning #2018
The man from Yvelines recognized as the victim of a work-related accident due to his electrosensitivity. It was ordered the Caisse primaire d’assurance maladie to pay the claimant 1,600 euros, plus 2,000 euros in legal costs.
https://www.europe1.fr/societe/yvelines-un-homme-reconnu-victime-daccident-du-travail-en-raison-de-son-electrosensibilite-3775628

#EHS #Spain #Winning #2019
The High Court of Justice of Aragón (TSJA) has confirmed a ruling that links the electrosensitivity contracted by an employee of an energy company as the cause of an occupational accident derived from his work as an engineer in electrical transformation centers.
https://www.elperiodicodearagon.com/aragon/2019/01/08/tsja-vincula-electrosensibilidad-accidentes-laborales-46693611.html

#EHS #France #Winning #2019
The Administrative Court of Cergy-Pontoise ordered the public body employing a research technician to recognize his electro-hypersensitivity as attributable to his work – the equivalent for civil servants of recognition as an occupational disease.
https://www.priartem.org/EHS-Nouvelle-avancee-judiciaire-en.html
https://rfsiteevaluations.weebly.com/blog/archives/04-2019

#EHS #USA #Winning #2021
California Appellate Court holds that Wi-Fi sickness is a disability. After the school district installed a new Wi-Fi system, the plaintiff teacher complained of headaches and other symptoms caused by exposure to the electromagnetic waves

Verdict:
https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar_case?case=3952106716981452997&q=Brown+v.+Los+Angeles+Unified+School+District&hl=en&as_sdt=2006&as_vis=1

#EHS #France #Winning #2024
Philippe Tribaudeau is a severely electrohypersensitive man who lives in a camper in the forest in the south of France, in a place without mobile coverage. The national forest management agency wanted to evict him, but a court has ruled that this is not allowed. The judge points to the right to housing on site and the right to respect for health in the event of extreme electrohypersensitivity.
https://www.stopumts.nl/doc.php/Juridische%20Informatie/13016/franse_rechtbank_beschermt_persoon_met_ehs

#Cancer #Israel? #USA? #Out-of-court-settlement #2013
Now an Israeli who has been using his cell phone inside his bomb shelter (bad idea) has been diagnosed with a cancer he says he got from using his cell phone. In an out of court settlement, the Israeli cell phone company Partner has agreed to give him $100,000. The plaintiff was eventually awarded a sum of NS 400,000 ($108,000) in an “out of court” settlement.

#Cancer #SouthKorea #Winning #2017
The family of a Samsung employee who died of a brain tumour should be entitled to state compensation for occupational disease.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/samsung-south-korea-lee-yoon-jung-wins-compensation-brain-tumor

#Cancer #Italy #Winning #2017
The Court of Florence confirmed the link between prolonged mobile phone use and an acoustic nerve tumor in a sales employee who used a phone for 2-3 hours daily over ten years. INAIL was ordered to grant him a disability pension pension of 16%.
https://www.dottnet.it/articolo/20746/tumore-da-uso-del-cellulare-altra-condanna-per-l-inail

#Cancer #Italy #Winning #2019
The Court of Appeal of Turin confirms the link between a head tumour and mobile phone use
Working process no. 721/2017, Roberto Romeo v. INAIL
– Concluded in 1st instance in Ivrea with the conviction of INAIL: Judgment No. 96/2017 published on 21.4.2017.
– Appeal by INAIL on 31.8.2017
– The Court of Appeal of Turin, with judgment no. 904/2019, confirms the Conviction in 1st instance of INAIL. Audience on 3.12.2019, judgment published on 13.1.2020.

https://www.phonegatealert.org/en/the-court-of-appeal-of-turin-confirms-the-link-between-a-head-tumour-and-mobile-phone-use

#Cancer #Italy #Winning #2019
The Labor Court of Monza ruled against INAIL, awarding compensation to an airport worker from Linate and Malpensa who developed a 38% disability due to excessive mobile phone use. Assisted by lawyers from Ambrosio & Commodo, he used a cordless phone and two mobile devices for up to 4 hours daily, always holding the phone on the left side to keep his right hand free.
https://oasisana.com/2019/04/03/tribunale-di-monza-sentenza-telefoninocancro-risarcito-il-lavoratore-danneggiato-in-un-ambiente-da-5g-esclusiva-assoluta-oasi-sana/

#Cancer #USA #InProcess #2021
Children’s Health Defense Chairman Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. is part of the legal team representing the family of Frank Aaron Walker, who died at age 49 from an aggressive brain cancer linked to cell phone radiation.

#Cancer #Italy #Winning #2021
The Florence Court of Appeal (ruling no. 390/2021) set a precedent by recognizing the link between multiple myeloma, a hematologic cancer, and long-term radiofrequency exposure in an Enel technician handling telecom infrastructure. Initially denied by INAIL (the national institute of public insurance of workers), the worker from Lucca won the case, though the ten-year legal battle ended only after his passing.
https://www.inca.it/notizie/999-malattie-professionali-rischi-per-esposizione-ad-onde-elettromagnetiche.html?pagina=22

#Cancer #Italy #Winning #2022
He gets cancer due to cell phone use: Inail condemned to pay the worker an income.

For 13 years he used the telephone for an average of 2.5 hours a day for work purposes. When the former technician discovered that he was suffering from a benign tumor in his ear, he asked INAIL to grant him an occupational sickness pension. The Court of Appeal of Turin ruled in his favor.

Labor case no. 496/2020, Mr. X (name unknown, 36 years old, employee at Cogne Acciai) had in 2020
litigated against INAIL because the latter had refused him a return on his investment.
– The Regional Court of Aosta, by judgment no. 25/2020, published on July 4, 2020, ordered INAIL to pay a monthly return.
– The Court of Appeal of Turin, in 2nd instance, has confirmed the judgment of Aosta and in the audience of 5.10.2022 condemned INAIL again: Judgment No. 519/2022, published on 3/11/2022.

https://torino.repubblica.it/cronaca/2022/11/05/news/si_ammala_di_tumore_per_luso_del_cellulare_condannata_inail_a_riconoscere_una_rendita_al_lavoratore-373067659

#Towers #Italy #Winning #2010
Vatican radio waves blamed for high cancer risk.
A court-ordered study has found that electromagnetic waves beamed by Vatican Radio leave residents living near the station’s antennas at a higher risk of cancer.
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-10634977
https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/vatican-masts-blamed-for-causing-cancer-in-children-2026765.html

#Towers #Taiwan #Winning #2011
A lawsuit was filed in the Kaohsiung District Court against the operator Cunghwa Telecom (CHT) alleging illegal installation of a mobile phone base station (MPBS) in an occupied residential building.
http://wuja.weebly.com/lawsuit.html

#Towers #Health #Slovakia #Winning #2018
The Main Court confirmed that a citizen has the right to be a participant in construction bureaucratic proceedings if a telecommunications transmitter is being built near him.

#Towers #Health #Pakistan #Winning #2019
The Peshawar High Court (PHC) on Wednesday directed the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to remove 20 base transmission system towers and microwave antennas of mobile phone companies from residential areas, as hazardous radiations cause serious diseases and health problems.
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/422734-hazardoUSA-radiation-phc-directs-epa-to-remove-20-cellular-

#Towers #Bangladesh #Winning #2019
The High Court Division in a full verdict in the case of mobile tower radiation effect has issued 12-point directives including imposition of a ban on installation of mobile or telecommunication towers on the rooftops of residential area, educational institutions, hospitals, jail premises, heritage sites, playgrounds and places of worship.
https://www.newagebd.net/article/87920/hc-orders-removal-of-mobile-towers-from-sensitive-areas

#Towers #Health #Netherlands #Winning #2020
The ruling of the Gelderland District Court (AWB 19/2184) – in conjunction with ruling AWB 19/2213 – on December 18, 2020 is of great importance because the judge rules that increased health risks (very well) below the exposure guidelines cannot be ruled out. The court also rules that the health interests of local residents who are sensitive to radiation must be taken into account in the weighing of interests. In Dutch case law, it is the first time that exposure limits are no longer leading due to advancing scientific insight.

https://letstalkabouttech.nl/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/20201231-Telegraaf-Binnenland-NL-Gezondheid-boven-mast.pdf

#Towers #Health #Netherlands #Winning #2021
In the Central Netherlands District Court’s opinion, it cannot be ruled out that there are health risks associated with the presence of a transmission mast. In the opinion of the court, it is therefore not excluded that claimants will experience significant consequences from the transmission tower in the context of possible health risks. The court finds that claimants should at least be able to have a substantive discussion about this in the objection.
https://www.stopumts.nl/doc.php/Juridische%20Informatie/12796/uitspraak_rechtbank_midden-nederland_bij_omgevingsvergunning_voor_het_realiseren_van_een_zendmast

#Towers #Health #Netherlands #Winning #2021
KPN must first provide facts about exposure risks before a controversial 5G mast in the town Emst may be built. This is evident from an interim judgment in a lawsuit filed by the Vereniging Milieuzorg Epe. With this, a lower court is once again putting the brakes on the construction of transmission masts: the health risks must not be taken too lightly.
https://www.stopumts.nl/doc.php/Juridische%20Informatie/12741/nog_een_rechter_die_op_de_rem_trapt_bij_5g-mast_kpn_moet_in_emst_eerst_met_risicofeiten_komen

#Towers #Health #USA #Winning #2022
Residents have won a David and Goliath battle to stop a giant 5G mast from being sited right next to their conservation area.
https://www.miltonkeynes.co.uk/news/people/telecoms-giant-defeated-in-appeal-to-site-5g-mast-in-one-of-the-most-scenic-areas-in-milton-keynes-3731172

#Towers #Health #Germany #Winning #2022
The German court clarified in the lawsuit that property owners who rent out premises for base stations and mobile towers assume responsibility for the health consequences of this activity. Although the radiation is lower than the relevant reference values ​​​​from the authorities, this does not mean that the property owner is not responsible for the negative health consequences.

Swedish article: https://www.stralskyddsstiftelsen.se/2022/07/05/domstol-fastighetsagare-delansvariga-for-halsoskador-av-mobilbasstationer/

German article: https://www.diagnose-funk.org/aktuelles/artikel-archiv/detail?newsid=1846

English article: https://www.emfacts.com/2022/07/german-court-finds-property-owners-can-be-liable-for-health-impacts-from-base-station-antennas-on-their-property/

#Towers #Health #USA #Intervention #2024
Couple Who Fears Cell Tower Could Disrupt Pacemaker Wins Right to Intervene in AT&T Lawsuit

#School #Wifi #Italy #Winning #2019
In Florence the Court orders the Wifi to be turned off at school.
https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2019/01/28/a-firenze-il-tribunale-fa-spegnere-il-wifi-a-scuola-un-atto-straordinariamente-innovativo/4916086

#School #Wifi #UK #Winning #2022
Court ordered to turn off Wi-Fi at a school in UK. Upper Tribunal requires council to secure EHCP for student who is hypersensitive to Wi-Fi signals.
https://www.localgovernmentlawyer.co.uk/education-law/394-education-news/51400-upper-tribunal-requires-council-to-secure-ehcp-for-student-who-is-hypersensitive-to-wi-fi-signals

#Radiation #USA #Winning #1982
A.Yannon, wins claim for husband Samuel Yannon, who died on June 10, 1974. He was a radio technician assigned to a special service unit which monitored and repaired microwave transmission units at the Empire State Building.
https://www.leagle.com/decision/198232786ad2d2411289

#Radiation #Australia #Winning #1999
A 1992 worker compensation case, Melbourne Victoria due to symptoms of chronic fatigue syndrome in the employment attributed to exposure to EMF due to proximity to an electrical substation.
https://www.emfacts.com/download/The_Ross_House_Electrical_Substation.pdf

#Radiation #Phones #Italy #Winning #2019
In a victory for advocates of precaution, an Italian court has ordered the government to launch a campaign to advise the public of the health risks from mobile and cordless phones.
https://microwavenews.com/short-takes-archive/italian-decision-precaution

#Radiation #USA #Winning #2021
EHT Wins in Historic Decision, Federal Court Orders FCC to Explain Why It Ignored Scientific Evidence Showing Harm from Wireless Radiation.

https://ehtrust.org/in-historic-decision-federal-court-finds-fcc-failed-to-explain-why-it-ignored-scientific-evidence-showing-harm-from-wireless-radiation

#Radiation #USA #Winning #2021
‘Historic Win’: CHD Wins Case Against FCC on Safety Guidelines for 5G and Wireless

Materials: https://childrenshealthdefense.org/defender/landmark-5g-case-against-fcc-hearing-set-jan-25/

#Radiation #Belgium #InProcess #2022
Radiation court case against Belgium and the EU – State of Play. The electromagnetic exposure limits in force in Europe amount to a novel form of torture.

#Radiation #SmallCells #Health #USA #Winning #2022
Judge says village’s denial of small cell applications was legal and reasonable.
https://mailchi.mp/f866723851bc/breaking-victory-against-5g-in-flower-hill

#Radiation #SmallCells #Health #USA #Winning #2022
A New York court has banned the installation of 5G cell towers after evidence showed they pose a danger to human health.
https://www.stopumts.nl/doc.php/Juridische%20Informatie/12868/amerikaanse_rechtbank_stopt_%E2%80%98gevaarlijke%E2%80%99_installatie_van_5g-zendmasten_…

#Radiation #5G #UK #InProcess #2020
They have issued a claim in the High Court for Judicial Review against the Department for Culture, Media and Sport and the Department for Communities, Housing and Local Government in relation to their decision to remove planning permission requirements for masts, antennae and associated equipment.
https://www.5gemfreview2020.com/the-case

#Radiation #5G #UK #InProcess #2022
The Court of Appeal in UK has granted permission for the case to proceed on grounds concerning 1) the failure to provide adequate information to the public about the risks of adverse health effects, 2) how individuals can avoid or minimize these risks and 3) the failure to provide adequate and sufficient reasons for not investigating and identifying the adverse health effects and risks of adverse health effects from 5G technology. The case will now be sent back to the Administrative Court and is now awaiting the directions as to the full hearing.
https://signstop5g.eu/en/news/a-legal-victory-for-anyone-fighting-the-rollout-of-5g

#5G #CostaRica #InProcess #2024
Costa Rica officially filed a complaint against Huawei. The accusations include fraud, bribery, influence peddling, and actions against the public treasury related to contracts for 3G and 5G deployment.
https://interestofjustice.substack.com/p/costa-rica-criminally-sues-huawei

#5G #Netherlands #InProcess #2024
The EHS Foundation appealed against the auction of the 3.5 GHz frequency. They request to suspend the intended auction until the court has heard the appeal of Stichting EHS and has made a decision on it.
https://stichtingehs.nl/nieuwsberichten/stichting-ehs-in-beroep-tegen-de-veiling-van-de-35-ghz-frequentie/

#5G #Netherlands #Winning #2021
Judge bans rollout of 3.5 GHz frequency band due to it already being used by Imarsat.
https://www.stopumts.nl/doc.php/Juridische%20Informatie/12755/rechter_verbiedt_uitrol_van_de_35_ghz_frequentieband_vanwege_het_al_in_gebruik_zijn_door__imarsat

#HighVoltage #Animals #France #Winning #2022
The court in Coutances (Manche) sentenced the company Réseau de transport d’enseignement (RTE) , a subsidiary of EDF, to pay a little more than 460,000 euros to a dairy farm in La Manche. The court thus recognized RTE’s liability, attributing half of the damage to the passage of the Cotentin-Maine very high voltage (THT) line near the farm.
www.lefigaro.fr/conjoncture/tres-haute-tension-rte-condamne-a-verser-plus-de-450-000-euros-a-des-eleveurs-20220603
Final verdict 2025: blog.ttla-avocats.com/2025/03/19/victoire-pour-un-eleveur-de-la-manche-contre-rte/

#Towers #Animals #France #Winning #2022
The administrative court in Clermont-Ferrand ordered 4G antenna switch-off over cow health concerns.
https://www.connexionfrance.com/news/french-court-orders-4g-antenna-switch-off-over-cow-health-concerns/181324

#Space #France #Winning #2022
France’s Conseil d’Etat court is revoking the license [PDF] authorizing Elon Musk’s Starlink outfit to use two frequency bands to provide satellite internet in France.
https://www.theregister.com/2022/04/06/starlink_france_license

#SAR #Phones #France #InProcess #2021
The Government filed a formal objection to the EU Commission. They propose a measurement of SAR in direct contact with the body.
https://www.stopumts.nl/doc.php/Juridische%20Informatie/12790/sar_of_cell_phone__france_files_a_formal_objection_to_the_eu_commission

#SAR #Phones #USA #InProcess #2023
A new step was taken on January 23, 2023 regarding the class action lawsuit filed in the United States against Apple. The plaintiffs, alleging that the brand’s iPhones exceed regulatory Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) limitations in real-world use, filed suit with the Supreme Court, the nation’s highest court.

#SmartMeters #USA #California #Winning #2012
HEALTH — Plantiff claimed negative health effects after smart meter was installed (Legal Documents).
The judge ordered the Utilities company pay for health damages or remove the meter! (Settlement Documents)

#SmartMeters #USA #Hawaii #Winning #2012
Privacy, Constitutional Violations, Security Risks – Adam Asquith filed for a Federal Injunction against the instillation of smart meters (Court Filing DocumentsNews Story.
The Utilities Company offered a settlement (Settlement Document) and agreed NOT to install a smart meter on the plaintiff’s property. (News report)

#SmartMeters #USA #Hawaii #Winning #2012
DISCRIMINATION – Mark Naea, a neighbor of Adam Asquith (who won his case against smart meters) filed a formal complaint (Legal Document) that he should not have to pay the court fees and file a separate case to get the opt-out option that was court awarded to his neighbor.
The Public Utilities Commission ordered (Legal Document) Kauai Island Utility Cooperative(KIUC) to address  his complaint.

#SmartMeters #USA #Maine #Winning #2012
HEALTH, SAFETY, PRIVACY, PROPERTY RIGHTS, CONSTITUTIONAL VIOLATION, DISCRIMINATION — A legal complaint objecting to multiple aspects of smart meters. Overview
The court ruled that the Utilities company DID NOT adequately address health and safety concerns and now must do so. Bangor Daily News

Update 6/4/15: After a 3 year PUC investigation into the health and safety of smart meters following the Supreme Court remand mentioned previously, the Commission ruled smart meters were basically safe enough. There was no vote held by the two commissioners and one of them recognized RF could probably cause adverse health effects and thought no cost opt outs [using a smart meter with transmitter disabled] should be available when suggested by a physician. Because the opinion made little sense and Central Maine Power never met their statutory burden to show safety was ensured with smart meters, opponents have appealed the decision, once more to the Maine Supreme Judicial Court. At this point, appellants brief has been filed, appellee’s brief is due June 30th and then opponents have 14 days to file a response. After this, oral arguments will be scheduled. More information and updates on the case can be found here.

#SmartMeters #USA #Portland #Winning #2012
HEALTH, CONSTITUTIONAL PRIVACY, SAFETY — Complaint that the PUC (Public Utilities Commission) did not address safety, Constitutional Privacy and health concerns. (New Story on Outcome)
The Supreme Judicial Court findings are that they did not properly address these problems (health and safety) and MUST do so. The Court not agree the Privacy concerns were not addressed.

#SmartMeters #Canada #Winning #2013
On July 18, 2013, Bill Bennett, Minister of Energy and Mines for the BC Provincial Liberals, made the following statement by way of press release announcing BC Hydro’s “Meter Choices Program”: “As we have said, nobody will be forced to take a smart meter. I believe that this is a fair and reasonable solution for all British Columbians”.
https://emrabc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/Lawsuit_Against_BC_Hydro_Proceeding.pdf

#SmartMeters #France #Winning #2017
EHS recognitised as a disability. The Court of First Instance orders ENEDIS in summary proceedings not to install a RF Linky smartmeter. In a decision handed down in 2017, the interim relief judge of the Court: Tribunal de Grande Instance has just forbidden SA ENEDIS to install a “Linky” meter in the home of a residents of who refused to install this smartmeter.
http://www.next-up.org/pdf/TGI_Grenoble_Ordonnance_Refere_EHS_Contre_Installation_Linky_ENEDIS_20_09_2017.pdf

#SmartMeters #France #Winning #2019
Following a court ruling, 13 electrosensitive Linky anti-meter users will benefit from the installation of a filter to protect them from electromagnetic waves. The Tribunal de Grand Instance de Bordeaux has ruled in favor of 13 of the 206 plaintiffs who took legal action against the installation of this electricity meter created by Enedis.
https://www.femmeactuelle.fr/sante/news-sante/compteur-linky-la-justice-donne-raison-a-13-plaignants-electrosensibles-2077743

#SmartMeters #France #Winning #2023
A man who claimed to be suffering from headaches due to his Linky meter has won a court battle to have it removed. Joseph Cascina from Saint-André-le-Puy (Loire) reported hearing a “constant whistling” in his head after its installation.
einarflydal.com/2025/03/17/franske-medier-melder-domstol-palegger-fjerning-av-hele-ams-maleren/

#SmartMeters #Belgium #Flanders #Winning #2021
A number of people from VEHS Flanders and Beperk de Straling filed an appeal with the Constitutional Court to annul the mandatory installation of the wireless smart meter for electricity and gas. Constitutional Court keeps the installation of the wireless smart meter for electricity and gas mandatory but recognizes the right to a wired smart meter. In order to protect themselves from electromagnetic radiation, the Constitutional Court stated that any grid user can opt for wired communication instead of wireless communication.
vehs.be/beroep-tegen-verplichte-draadloze-digitale-meter-ingediend/
vehs.be/grondwettelijk-hof-erkent-recht-op-een-bekabelde-digitale-meter/

#SmartMeters #Belgium #Flanders #Loss #2023
While the rollout of the wireless smart meter for electricity and gas has been accelerated in 2020 (80% of meters must be installed by the end of 2024), the availability of the wired meter has not. Thus, in this long transition period, an obligation applies without the availability of the wired alternative. For this reason, this accelerated rollout was appealed on 16 October 2020.

The court delayed this case until the ‘wired electricity meter’ was in available, i.e. until after 1 January 2023. In its ruling 256,712 of the Council of State (RvS) on 8 June 2023, this appeal was then dismissed because the applicants had no interest (anymore) in challenging the contested articles.

In the beginning of 2025, there still is no wired smart gas meter.

#SmartMeters #Belgium #Flanders #Winning #2022
Third appeal against mandatory smart meters for electricity and gas: Appeal on the non-binding installation of electronic meter without communication device. In the Energy Decree there was provided that an electronic meter without communication device could be installed when asked by the grid user, but the grid operator did not want to install this kind of meter. The Constitutional Court decided that the grid operator has the obligation to install this kind of meter on request of the grid user. Despite this, grid operator still refuses to install such meter.

#SmartMeters #Belgium #Flanders #Winning #2023
Appeal against wireless water meter. The court stated that the decree does not stipulate that the digital water meter should only communicate wirelessly and that, once wired meters are available, the Flemish government should provide the right to opt for a wired digital meter.

#SmartMeters #Belgium #Flanders #Dismissed #2024
Appeal against the remotely readable heat meter: the appeal was dismissed but the Council argues that the decree does not stipulate that wireless communication can be enforced. The Council concluded: after all, remote readability can just as easily be achieved via cabling, so the decree does not mandate wireless communication that exposes users to (additional) electromagnetic radiation, with all the disadvantages that this entails for maintaining and protecting a healthy environment. In practice, though, the heat meter is wireless as standard

#SmartMeters #Belgium #Flanders #InProcess #2025
A persistent refuser of a digital meter has been summoned and will therefore have to appear in court. The grid operator continues to pressure people to accept a wireless smart meter.
https://vehs.be/zwicht-niet-voor-de-digitale-meter/

#SmartMeters #USA #California #InProcess #2010
WRONGFUL DEATH DUE TO FIRE CAUSED BY SMART METER — Larry Nikkel died in a fire believed to be caused by smart meter.

#SmartMeters #USA #InProcess #2010
WIRELESS COMPONENT OVER SMART METERS  — Smart Meters have been “mandated” in British Columbia, however Plantiff contests that the wireless component is part of the mandate.(Press Release) (News story) (Formal Letter of Complaint – legal Document) (Letter of Complaint- scroll down)

#SmartMeters #USA #California #InProcess #2012
HEALTH – Lawsuit filed against the CPUC (Central Public Utilities Commission) for ignoring evidence of harmful health effects of Smart Meters. (Latest updateLink on story

#SmartMeters #USA #InProcess #2010
SPYING – A top PG&E executive was caught spying and attempting to infiltrate a nonprofit to gather information about a forthcoming lawsuit. (Coverage of case) Curious and curiouser. (Legal Order to investigate)

#SmartMeters #USA #California #InProcess #2011
HEALTH, SAFETY, MISREPRESENTATION OF RADIATION LEVELS, VIOLATION OF AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT — Filed by an Electro-magnetic consulting firm, Wilner and Associates this Class Action Lawsuit list multiple ten grievances and is seeking $10,000 per customer who has experienced negative health effects. (Story) (Case Filing)

#SmartMeters #USA #Illinois #InProcess #2011
HEALTH, PRIVACY, HOMEOWNER’S RIGHTS, VIOLATION OF ILLINOIS “OPEN MEETINGS ACT”  — Residents have filed a federal lawsuit (News article) seeking an injunction to instillation (Court Documents) Up to date info on the case

#SmartMeters #USA #Alabama #Loss #2011
MISUSE OF FEDERAL MONIES DUE TO FIRE RISK — According to the lawsuit, the Don Baker, plaintiff, is an engineer and was an AMI smart grid project manager.  He alleges the smart meters were not properly tested, and were seriously flawed. He found that the Sensus iConA had a “tendency to drastically overheat, and melt or burn”.  He was asked to keep quiet and was eventually terminated for failing to do so.

Status: The fire issue was not the focus of the case, it was misuse of Federal Funds.The District Attorney chose not to pursue the case, not based on the fire hazard claims, but claiming Federal Money was not misused. (case documents)

#SmartMeters #USA #Texas #Loss #2011
OVERCHARGING — A class action lawsuit (Case documents) filed against Texan Utilities company Oncor. (News Story, Video)
Status: Case Dismissed (One analysis of why it failed)

#SmartMeters #USA #California #Loss #2011
OVERCHARGING — Initially an individual case alleging overcharging  of smart meters (Initial Filing), this turned into a class action lawsuit (News report).
Status: Initially SUCCESS! Then overturned. emfsafetynetwork.org

#Disqualification #USA #InProcess #2022
Public hearing of Wilma de Jong’s request for disqualification at the Council of State

#Cars #Georgia #Winning #2022
Because of an electromagnetic radiation, a man sued the Nissan LEAF (100% Electric Family Car) “for permanently damaging his health and for destroying his family and career, not to exceed $10 million“.
https://www.carcomplaints.com/news/2021/nissan-leaf-electromagnetic-radiation-lawsuit.shtml

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Europeans for Safe Connections (“we”) treats your personal data confidentially in compliance with the legal requirements of the Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (the GDPR). You do not provide us with any personal data in the ordinary browsing of the esc-info.eu ("website"). We only collect information that is insufficient to identify a person, but allows us to track simple statistics. View more
Cookies settings
Accept
Decline
Privacy & Cookie policy
Privacy & Cookies policy
Cookie name Active
The Europeans for Safe Connections (“we”) treats your personal data confidentially in compliance with the legal requirements of the Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (the General Data Protection Regulation).

Website

We are responsible for operating www.esc-info.eu (the “site”). During ordinary viewing, you can use these without providing us with personal information. We only collect information that is insufficient to identify a person but allows us to have an overview of simple statistics:
  • your browser programme’s name and its version,
  • your device’s operating system,
  • the (anonymised) IP-address of your device,
  • the exact time of your request,
  • the URL-address of the requested file or page,
  • the address of the website which pointed to our site (the Referrer URL),
  • the result of your request (the HTTP Status Code).
The site does not collect any information from social networks. If you click one of social media links you are redirected to those websites and there they collect themselves. If you will contact us via the contact form or subscribe to our newsletters, your name and email address will be recorded. In case of need to cancel the subscription to our newsletters, you can do so via the Unsubscribe link located in the footer of each newsletter, this will remove your name and email address from the system.
Save settings
Cookies settings